| |
|
|
Open World: The Truth About Globalisation
Philippe Legrain
Amazon.co.uk Review:
Philip Legrain's ambitiously titled Open World: The Truth about Globalisation
adds a new dimension to the debate on globalisation: a new defender of
the benefits of the global village. Having worked for both the World Trade
Organisation and The Economist, Legrain's credentials seem impeccable,
and he quickly launches into an impassioned defence of the benefits of
economic globalisation, enthusiastically attacking Naomi Klein's No Logo,
arguing that "the beauty of globalisation is that it can free people
from the tyranny of geography" in offering new possibilities for
international and global cooperation and cultural intermingling.
Legrain rejects the anti-globalisation argument that governments are losing
control to multinational companies, and that branding is taking over our
lives, offering a powerful critique of the recent TRIPS agreement. He
is also good on the extent to which "many of the worries about globalisation
echo age-old fears about decline". In arguing for a much more interventionist
model for the future of globalisation, Legrain follows the work of Anthony
Giddens and Will Hutton, but he lacks scope and authority of their economic
and political analysis to really add anything new to their radical democratic
positions. His cultural analysis is so weak that he repeatedly idealises
the new possibilities that globalisation provides; the claim that "we
increasingly define ourselves rather than let others define us" is
true for a privileged, but impossible to sustain for millions of people
in the developing world. Open World still has one eye closed to the downside
of globalisation.
-Jerry Brotton
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/ASIN/
034911644X/qid=1047892302/sr=2-1/ref=sr_2_3_1/202-2788745-1801433
|
|
|
|